Background and challenges to implementation:Guidelines
for implementation of FCTC Article 11 recommend Parties adopt health warnings
and messages that be consider scientific evidence and experiences in other
countries. Brazilian MoH has adopted health warnings that cover 100% of the
face in 2001 and that cover 30% of the front face in 2015. In 2017, ANVISA
opened a public consultation (PC) on new health warnings.
[Health Warning w/shadow under Public Consultation]Intervention or response:Civil society identified that the images
proposed by ANVISA were not in accordance with the Guideline's recommendations and
prepared a documentation considering all the effective design elements determined
by the Guideline and submitted in the PC System.
Results and lessons learnt:There were 100 contributions, two of which were
international, 39 from Rio de Janeiro and 16 from Rio Grande do Sul. There were
75 contributions made by citizens and 25 by companies. Ten contributions were
explicitly made by regulated sector. The most commented articles were 6, 5 and
7. Fifty-four percent disagree with the PC's text, 52.2% believe it does not
change or reduce the level of information for goods and services available to
the citizen and 58% believe the proposal´s impact on routines and activities
will be negative.
Conclusions and key recommendations:The
adoption of the new series of health warnings and messages is necessary because
the current ones are already in circulation for almost 10 years and their
impact on the population is reducing. PC are an important tool for social
participation for implementation of the National Tobacco Control Policy.
However, the contributions of the industry and its representatives are more
numerous due to the economic power and influence it has in some regions and
because of this, some results reflect their economic and political interests of
not regulating it.