What keeps healthcare professionals from advising their patients who smoke to quit? A large-scale cross-sectional study
More details
Hide details
1
Leiden University Medical Center, Public Health and Primary Care, Netherlands
Publication date: 2018-03-01
Tob. Induc. Dis. 2018;16(Suppl 1):A514
Download abstract book (PDF)
KEYWORDS
TOPICS
ABSTRACT
Background:
Quit-advice provided
by healthcare professionals effectively increases quit rates. Tobacco dependence
treatment guidelines therefore recommend providing quit-advice to all patients who smoke
(PWS), however, many healthcare professionals do not advise PWS to quit. This results
in worse patient outcomes and higher healthcare costs. We examined determinants
of providing quit-advice among a large sample of healthcare professionals from
different fields, most of which have not been included in research on tobacco
discouragement before.
Methods:
Online survey
among addiction specialists (n=13), anaesthesiologists (n=61), cardiologists
(n=23), dental hygienists (n=74), dentists (n=40), general practitioners (n=149),
internists (n=79), midwives (n=82), neurologists (n=29), ophthalmologist (n=25), paediatricians
(n=42), pulmonologists (n=121), surgeons (n=65), youth specialists (n=78) and
other physicians (n=74). Provision of quit-advice, and socio-cognitive determinants
of and environmental/patient barriers to using the Dutch Tobacco-dependence-guideline
were assessed (entire sample), as well as perceptions of smoking (subsample).
Results:
Most participants
(27%) advised the majority of PWS to quit, but only 16% advised all of them to
quit and 18% advised none to quit (16% half, 24% minority). Midwives were most
likely to advise all PWS to quit (42%). Multivariate logistic regression analysis
(n=760) showed that providing quit-advice (to all/majority vs. half/minority/none
of PWS) was significantly associated with stronger intentions to use the guideline,
stronger role perceptions, and sufficient training in smoking-cessation-care. Those
who mentioned lack of reimbursement as a barrier to providing smoking-cessation-care
were more likely to provide quit-advice, possibly because particularly those
who are more involved in tobacco treatment experience reimbursement as a
barrier. Furthermore, participants who perceived continuing smokers to lack
willpower were less likely to provide quit-advice (n=446).
Conclusions:
Quit-advice is
provided less often than recommended. This may be improved by training, and by making
healthcare professionals more aware of their role in tobacco discouragement,
and the role of addiction (vs. willpower) in continued smoking.
CITATIONS (1):
1.
Physician Reluctance to Intervene in Addiction
Melinda Campopiano von Klimo, Laura Nolan, Michelle Corbin, Lisa Farinelli, Jarratt D. Pytell, Caty Simon, Stephanie T. Weiss, Wilson M. Compton
JAMA Network Open